Synthetic Data and Archives: Friend or Foe?

Introduction

Synthetic data—artificially generated datasets that mimic real-world information—has emerged as a powerful tool for training AI, testing systems, and preserving privacy. But when archives serve as the source material for synthetic data, questions of compliance, governance, and ethics arise. Is synthetic data a friend that protects privacy, or a foe that amplifies risks? This blog unpacks the dual role of synthetic data in the archiving ecosystem.

---

What is Synthetic Data?

• Definition: Data generated by algorithms to replicate statistical properties of real datasets.
• Use Cases: AI training, software testing, simulation, and compliance-safe data sharing.
• Sources: Often derived from sensitive archives such as healthcare records, financial transactions, or communication logs.

---

Opportunities of Synthetic Data from Archives

1. Privacy Preservation

• Synthetic data can reduce reliance on exposing sensitive records for training or testing.
• Helps organizations comply with GDPR and HIPAA by avoiding direct use of personal data.

2. AI Innovation

• Expands training datasets without compromising confidentiality.
• Enables development of models for rare events where real-world examples are scarce.

3. Safer Collaboration

• Allows sharing of datasets across teams or partners without exposing raw archives.

---

Risks and Pitfalls

1. Re-Identification Risk

• Poorly generated synthetic data may retain patterns that allow individuals to be identified.
• Attackers can exploit overlaps between synthetic and real data.

2. Regulatory Ambiguity

• Regulators disagree on whether synthetic data derived from personal archives is truly outside the scope of privacy laws.
• Schrems II, GDPR, and CCPA may still apply if data can be linked back.

3. Data Integrity Concerns

• Synthetic data may introduce statistical bias or inaccuracies that compromise AI outcomes.

4. Over-Reliance

• Using synthetic data exclusively may blind organizations to real-world anomalies.

---

Best Practices for Using Archives to Generate Synthetic Data

1. Assess Re-Identification Risk: Use differential privacy and testing frameworks to minimize exposure.
2. Document Provenance: Maintain audit trails of how synthetic data was generated from archives.
3. Blend Synthetic and Real Data: Combine both for more balanced AI training and testing.
4. Validate Statistical Integrity: Ensure synthetic datasets reflect real-world distributions accurately.
5. Monitor Regulatory Updates: Stay informed on how laws treat synthetic datasets linked to archives.

---

Friend or Foe?

Synthetic data is neither inherently good nor bad—it is a tool. When used responsibly, it enhances privacy, innovation, and collaboration. But without safeguards, it can create compliance blind spots and reputational risk.

---

Conclusion

For organizations managing sensitive archives, synthetic data represents both opportunity and challenge. By embedding strong governance, validation, and transparency practices, synthetic data can become a friend that strengthens AI and compliance programs—rather than a foe that undermines them.